A few weeks ago, a guest post on friend and fellow racial-equity advocate Tom Adams’ website discussed an interesting reaction to visiting baroque churches in Italy during a recent sabbatical. Tom’s friend, Tuck Grinnell, found himself overwhelmed by “too many paintings – too many angels” and thinking about “our human tendency to continually renovate our churches, our houses, our neighborhoods. Every generation, it seems, has felt the need to redo, or redecorate, or redevelop.”
There’s certainly a deep truth to that—and perhaps it’s a visceral response to the modernist Western love affair with the newest, brightest, and shiniest things. But my mind went in a different direction. I found myself thinking of the churches I visited in Italy (like the one above in Siena) and the overwhelming sensory input that people receive in a place like that.
I find a real parallel in the flood of information coming to us through the Internet and social media these days. It can be too much to take in—and the contrast with monastic church buildings like this one (also in Italy) is stark. These monks surely realized the importance of not being overwhelmed by too many paintings, angels, and gold accents. Here, the eye and heart are less distracted. The monks were probably more able to focus on God because there wasn’t so much around to divert their attention.
I don’t believe this means we need to shut off the flow of information entirely. The monks still used the Bible, prayer books, and the writings of their forefathers in the monastic tradition. They were edified perhaps inspired by the few religious decorations deliberately placed around the sanctuary. They were also stimulated by God’s creation when they walked outside the church doors and were confronted with the fields, flowers, and flocks that were given into their care.
We also need to choose just a few wise voices and images and use them to help us reflect more deeply, especially when we are overwhelmed. I periodically remove myself from email lists when I find I’m not making time to read what those worthy organizations and individuals send—even though they are worthy. The point is that we cannot do it all. We are human beings, not machines.
And yes, I recognize that I am, in essence, also inviting you to consider whether my reflections are helpful at this point in your life or not. That’s okay. This blog is not a capitalist endeavor for me. It is a window into my spiritual life that I choose to share with whomever the Spirit brings in my virtual door.
Perhaps that sense of becoming overwhelmed is resonating for you too. As I noted two weeks ago, this is for me a season of allowing the ground to lie fallow. One way to do that will be to slow the stream of digital input. I’ll suggest another image next week, rising out of last year’s pilgrimage in the Holy Land.
Meanwhile, I invite you to consider what level of stimulation feels right for you in this season of your life. What changes do you need to make in daily rhythms or sensory input to support a deeper connection with yourself and the divine?
I remember having a similar experience when we visited Europe several years ago… I wanted to see all the churches I could – then found myself saying”enough” and seeking solitude with no ornate altars or stained windows in sight!
The “overwhelm” is so True on many levels. Sometimes when I even look in my closet and think Why all this? As I sit and sort all the digital input I am reminded of my “goal” this year – to simplify simplify simplify! Thank you ….
Please doesn’t stop writing or sharing your wisdom and insights!
You’re welcome, Joyce. I’m glad my reflections resonated so well with yours. Blessings on your goal to simplify this year…and don’t worry, I have every intention to keep going with this!
Peace,
Shirin
Shirin, as always, I appreciate your thoughtfulness and deliberation. My wife and I serve on a team which determines what the sanctuary “decorations” will be for the worship space. Often we begin the seasons of Lent and Advent with a very spare and plain sanctuary, adding items and elements as we approach Easter or Christmas. I particularly love the plainness of the worship space in those seasons. May God bless you richly in this fallow time.
Thank you, John for sharing your liturgical leadership experience. I recall how powerful it was to worship at the SSJE monastery in Cambridge MA as the white Easter flowers slowly changed colors each week until they were fiery red on Pentecost. Such a simple and profound transformation. Thank you for evoking such blessed memories and I’m glad my musings spoke to you.
Peace,
Shirin
Having visited many European cathedrals I also find myself wondering about the sacrifices made by the people who built and decorated them – were they like the slave labor of Egypt? How many died falling as they built or painted such high ceilings? What was the motivation for creating such masterpieces?
Thank you, Pat for these powerful questions. I’ve read that the goal (or at least a goal) was to recreate heaven on earth. But yes, at what cost? So important to remember the voiceless and to celebrate also how their talents speak to us today.
Peace,
Shirin
I have a similar reaction to ornate churches from any era.
We were in Quito, Ecuador recently. A bustling city alive with poverty. The main cathedral is baroque of course and heavily ornate. In 1996 one wing was consumed by fire and repaired at enormous cost. It seemed like a terrible way to spend money. Much as they think it will cost at least one billion to repair Notre Dame.
I think of St. Francis and his focus on the Mendicant life. He wanted no riches, yet the first thing the monks did after he died was built an elaborate basilica.
These “buildings” seem to reflect priorities that are contrary to a commitment to the poor.
As for images and media, I have deactivated my FB and Twitter accounts. I don’t like what happens in me when I see images or read comments online. So I’m out for now 😉
Thank you for sharing your perspective on this issue Damien. Yes, rebuilding fancy churches at great cost while people starve at the doors does seem pretty backward—and out of step with Jesus and his message.
May your step away from social media bring you peace and clarity about what you are called to do with that time and energy for the sake of the poor.
Peace,
Shirin
My, my! I resonate with all of the comments below. I, too, have visited many baroque churches in Europe and South America, and found that after a while, they all blended together and became simply overwhelming. The comments regarding slave labor and expenditures of such fortunes while the poor starved are so right on, considering Jesus’ focus on those very people. He must be saying, “People, people! You got it all wrong!”
As for media input, I delete some posts without even opening them. You’re so right, Shirin–we’re only people who can’t process every bit of info that comes at us. Thanks for the reminder!
Thank you, Aston, for adding to this conversation. I’m glad my post and others’ responses resonated with you. Yes, I can imagine Jesus shaking his head…you’re welcome for the reminders!
Peace,
Shirin